History Files
 
 

 

Ancient Syria

Questions About Tuba

Edited from John Hopkins University News, 9 May 1994

Archaeologist Glenn Schwartz embarked in 1994 on an expedition to north-western Syria to study the mysteries of ancient Tuba, a four thousand year-old city state that suddenly collapsed and later resurrected itself.

It's a scenario that has been played out in various regions of the world over the millennia. Cities and whole civilisations disappear, some for no obvious reasons.

'The question is why are these early civilisations so brittle?' said Dr Schwartz, an assistant professor of Near Eastern studies at the Johns Hopkins University. 'One reason that's been suggested lately is climate change.

'It's been suggested that these early urban civilisations were so fragile because they placed extensive demands on their environments, continually intensifying their agriculture to feed more people. The added stress from a few dry years may have been the straw that broke the camel's back.'

That's just one theory that Schwartz planned to investigate during the first of what would likely be several seasons of research at Umm el-Marra, the probable site of an ancient city called Tuba, located to the east of the modern city of Aleppo. Umm el- Marra was a medium-sized city, and archaeological evidence indicates that it was the largest metropolis on the Jabbul Plain, an intersection of ancient trade routes.

Located to the south-west was the ancient city of Ebla, where Italian excavators in the 1970s stunned the archaeological world by discovering a sophisticated urban civilisation, one which dated back to about 2400 BC. The find came complete with seventeen thousand tablets that were inscribed with ancient writings.

That discovery revealed that Mesopotamia and Egypt were not the only early centres of advanced urban civilisation in the Near East.

'It completely changed our ideas of what was going on in Syria in this period,' Schwartz said. 'It was always assumed that Syria was not even literate in this period.'

Glenn Schwartz, who was collaborating with archaeologist Hans Curvers from the University of Amsterdam, left for Syria on 1 May 1994 and was expected to return in mid-July. They had worked together on previous research into the important roles played by rural towns in ancient civilisation, particularly at the site of Tell al- Raqa'i, along the valley of the River Khabur in north-eastern Syria.

The research at Umm el-Marra would be different, since it dealt with what apparently was a political and economic centre, not a rural community.

The team's work would not be limited to uncovering the complexities of Tuba.

'We intend to conduct a regional study,' Schwartz said, noting that the archaeologists would conduct a survey of the entire Jabbul Plain. Hopkins graduate student Tawny Holm was to participate in the work, along with students from other institutions.

Researchers hoped to learn details of demographic changes, the development of cities, relationships between communities and their physical environments, and how those factors changed over time. One such environmental factor is climate, which may have presented a special social hardship in ancient Tuba. 'There seems to have been a drying-up in the third millennium,' Schwartz said. An extended drought might have contributed to the city's collapse around 2100 BC, as has also been shown to be the case across Mesopotamia.

But the fall of Tuba and its surrounding region is only half the story.

'I also want to go to the next step, which is working out how they managed to resurrect themselves after the disaster,' said Schwartz. 'You have a reappearance of large urban centres and healthy political states vying with one another shortly afterwards.'

'How do urban centres manage to re-invent themselves? How do they get up after they fall?'

Tuba, which was occupied for at least eleven hundred years, beginning in 2500 BC, enjoyed a second period of prosperity and power after the collapse around 2100 BC, becoming a major centre once again. In this period, Tuba was a 'subsidiary capital' of the kingdom of Yamkhad, an extensive but little-known state about which Schwartz also hoped to learn more.

The dig at Tell Umm el-Marra
The mud brick tombs contained decapitated animals, with the skulls on an adjacent ledge, alongside tombs at Tell Umm el-Marra in Syria

 

 

     
Original text copyright © John Hopkins University Press Department.